The federal high court on Friday permitted the former president's government to eliminate TPS benefits from over 300k Venezuelan nationals.
Justices' Interim Decision
The court members enacted an emergency order, which will stay active for the duration of the court case are ongoing, suspending a earlier judicial finding that had prevented the administration from ending protected immigration status for the migrants from Venezuela.
The dissenting members filed dissents.
Broader Immigration Policy
The Trump government has moved to withdraw various protections that permit foreign nationals to stay in the country and work legally, including revoking TPS for a combined 600k Venezuelans and Haitian migrants who were given legal status under the Biden administration.
TPS is awarded for periods of 18 months.
Prior Supreme Court Ruling
In the spring, the justices overturned a interim ruling that affected an additional 350k Venezuelan migrants whose legal status lapsed earlier this year.
The supreme court gave no reasoning at the time, which is typical in emergency appeals.
“The parallel conclusion that we decided in May is suitable here,” the court stated in an anonymous decision.
Impact on Migrants
Some migrants have become unemployed and residences while some have been taken into custody and expelled after the court acted the prior occasion, lawyers for the migrants informed the justices.
Disagreement from Justices
“I view today’s decision as yet another serious abuse of our emergency docket,” Ketanji Brown Jackson wrote. “Because, courteously, I cannot abide our ongoing, unnecessary and harmful intervention with cases pending in the lower courts while lives hang in the balance, I disagree.”
Background on TPS
Congress established TPS in 1990 to stop expulsions to countries undergoing calamities, civil strife or further unsafe circumstances.
The classification can be issued by the homeland security secretary.
District Judge's Ruling
The trial court judge found that the immigration agency acted “with unprecedented haste and in an atypical way … for the preordained purpose of accelerating the revocation of Venezuela’s TPS designation.”
In previous dismissing the government's interim application, a different jurist wrote for a unanimous three-judge appellate panel that the trial court had determined that DHS made its “decisions first and searched for a valid basis for those decisions afterward”.
Legal Arguments
The government's lead attorney had argued in the recent court documents that the prior decision should similarly affect the current case.
“This case is well-known to the court and involves the increasingly familiar and untenable situation of lower courts disregarding this court’s orders on the interim proceedings,” the lawyer wrote.
The consequence, he said, is that the “new order, just like the old one, blocked the vacatur and termination of TPS affecting over 300,000 migrants based on meritless legal theories”.